Female Priests in the Episcopal Church

by Louie Crew
Rutgers University

©1998 by Louie Crew. Use freely but only if you acknowledge Louie Crew as the author, cite this website, and send hard copy to Dr. Louie Crew, P. O. Box 30, Newark, NJ 07101.



What appears to be a decline in both orders after 1994 more likely reflects a lag in the time that ordinations actually get reported and recorded in The Clerical Directory. The Directory used for making these tallies appeared in electronic form in January of 1998, and it is highly unlikely that it had recorded the many ordinations that often take place in December. Nor does the graph include priests ordained during that period who have since died, because their records are no longer in the Clerical Directory. Click here to see the graph just of women.

In 1973, there were no women priests.  The 1998 Episcopal Clerical Directory contains ordination dates for all but one of 1,955 women priests.  Women now constitute 13.8% of those listed in the 1998 Episcopal Clerical Directory.


Women Priests in ECUSA's 100 Domestic Dioceses
(left to right in descending order of percent)

NMich

15

41.7%

U

15

26.8%

Roch

29

26.1%

Vt

22

25.9%

EO

8

24.2%

Ida

14

23.7%

Mo

23

22.5%

Ind

24

22.4%

Mass

103

22.1%

Cal

71

21.1%

NC

45

20.7%

ECR

29

20.4%

WK

1

20.4%

WDC

51

20.4%

Nwk

51

20.3%

At

41

20.0%

SD

11

20.0%

Nev

11

19.6%

Ia

17

19.3%

Ak

12

19.0%

Minn

39

18.8%

Mont

9

18.4%

EMich

11

18.3%

Be

19

18.3%

SO

32

17.9%

Ct

66

17.6%

RI

25

17.5%

Del

14

17.3%

WVa

17

17.2%

NwPa

9

17.0%

Va

63

16.5%

NH

17

16.5%

Me

21

16.4%

Mich

37

15.9%

Los

64

15.7%

CPa

16

15.5%

NY

83

15.4%

Md

39

15.4%

CNY

24

15.4%

SwVa

12

15.0%

Wyo

8

14.5%

Spok

9

14.5%

WMich

19

14.5%

Colo

29

14.0%

O

32

14.0%

WMo

13

13.7%

WNY

16

13.7%

ND

3

13.6%

RG

16

13.4%

Oly

31

13.1%

Haw

11

13.1%

Pa

47

12.9%

NCal

17

12.9%

Ky

9

12.9%

NJ

39

12.7%

Mil

13

12.5%

WTenn

8

12.5%

NwT

7

12.3%

USC

16

12.0%

Lex

8

11.9%

Chi

40

11.9%

Ore

18

11.7%

SVa

19

11.6%

Miss

13

11.4%

WNC

13

11.3%

EC

13

11.1%

Tenn

10

11.1%

Kan

10

10.8%

Okla

13

10.7%

Fla

15

10.6%

Ark

8

10.3%

SeFla

15

10.1%

ETenn

10

10.0%

SanD

12

10.0%

NI

6

9.5%

Pgh

12

9.4%

Az

13

9.1%

Tex

27

8.7%

WTex

12

8.3%

Ala

11

7.3%

CGC

7

6.9%

Dal

10

6.6%

Neb

5

6.2%

SwFla

9

5.4%

Spr

3

5.2%

LI

13

4.8%

Ga

5

4.7%

Eas

2

3.7%

WMass

19

3.7%

CFla

6

3.6%

Alb

5

3.0%

WLa

3

3.0%

La

3

2.8%

SC

3

2.5%

FdL

1

1.8%

Eau

0

zero%

FtW

0

zero%

NAM

0

zero%

Q

0

zero%

SJ

0

zero%

See also the the deployment of black women priests by diocese and the deployment of all black priests.

Women are distributed differently in the three orders of ordained ministry:

 

Deacons

Priests

Bishops

Women

31.7% 68.0% 0.3%

Men

7.9% 89.9% 2.2%
These same patterns are reflected in the portion of women in each of the three orders of ordained ministry:

Deacons

Women

45.8%

Men

54.2%

Priests

Women

13.8%

Men

86.2%

Bishops

Women

2.5%

Men

97.5%
In the 41 episcopal elections of bishops consecrated since 1/1/95, 22 (13.6%) of the 162 runners up were women, so the 2.5% will likely continue to increase.

Only 378 women priests are employed as rectors (9.7% of 3,902 rectors). Women priests are 17.7% of 1,062 vicars.

Women rectors have only one-fourth the share of male rectors in overseeing parishes of 1,000+ members. Only 1.4% of all female rectors now occupy such positions, compared with 5.2% of all male rectors and 4.4% of all black priests. Only five women are rectors of parishes with 1,000 or more members:

  1. The Rev. Carol Linda Anderson, R All SS 89-. Beverly Hills, CA Parish Size:1400-1499
  2. The Rev. Heather Elizabeth Cook, R S Andr 94-. York, PA Parish Size:1200-1299
  3. The Rev. Margaret B Gunness, R Chr 91-. Ridgewood, NJ Parish Size:1500-1599
  4. The Rev. Brenda Gail Husson, R S Jas 96-. New York, NY Parish Size:1800-1899
  5. The Rev. Rosemary Pickering Thomas, Abilene, TX Parish Size:1100-1199

Female Bishops

  1. Rt. Rev. Jane Dixon, Bishop Suffragan of Washington
  2. Rt. Rev. Barbara Harris, Bishop Suffragan of Massachusetts
  3. Rt. Rev. Carolyn Irish, Bishop of Utah
  4. Rt. Rev. Chilton Knudsen, Bishop of Maine
  5. Rt. Rev. Mary Adelia McLeod, Bishop of Vermont
  6. Rt. Rev. Catherine S. Roskam, Bishop Suffragan of New York
  7. Rt. Rev. Catherine (Cate) Waynick, Bishop of Indianapolis
  8. Rt. Rev. Geralyn Wolf, Bishop of Rhode Island

    Three more women are bishops in the Anglican Commmunion outside the USA

  9. Rt. Rev. Penelope Jamieson, Bishop of Dunedin, New Zealand
  10. Rt. Rev. Victoria Matthews, Bishop of Edmonton, Canada
  11. Rt. Rev. Ann Tottenham, Bishop Suffragan of Toronto (Credit Valley), Canada

Women deployed as rectors have the smallest average congregation of any subgroup that I have monitored:

Parish Size

bps' last parish lay deputies all deputies all rectors clergy deputies black rectors all congregations unmarried rectors female rectors

Average Parish Size of Selected Subgroups

Group

Avg. Parish Size

Bishops' parish upon election

747

Lay Deputies in 1997

518

All Deputies in 1997

466

All Rectors in 1998

433

Clergy Deputies in 1997

414

Black Rectors in 1998

260

All Congregations in 1998

215

Unmarried Rectors in 1998

211

Female Rectors in 1998

93

I have not computed averages of congregations overseen by vicars, priest-in-charge....., but those congregations are included in "All Congregations." To compute "All congregations" I divided the total number of confirmed communicants (1,592,653) by the total number of parishes (7,395) -- a reported in the 1998 Episcopal Church Annual. and I will continue to add new information to this report.

It seems like the same ole patriarchy to me.

Age

Women priests are on average ten years younger than male priests, (51.74 vs. 60.73). That is in large measure the result of the larger pool of retired clergy males. Women have not been ordained long enough to comprise a proportionate share of the elderly clergy.

Gender distribution by age group

Age

Male

Female

Under 40

75.9% 24.1%

40-49

72.8% 27.2%

50-59

75.5% 24.5%

60-69

86.9% 13.1%

70-79

93.2% 6.8%

80+

87.2% 12.8%

Age distribution by gender

Age

Male

Female

Under 40

4.8% 6.7%

40-49

17.3% 28.4%

50-59

26.8% 38.3%

60-69

27.5% 18.2%

70-79

20.9% 6.7%

80+

2.6% 1.7%

Although the average woman priest is younger than the average male, women priests were older upon ordination, 41.82 vs. 32.63 for the males. Also, women priests took an average of 1.22 years to move from the diaconate to priesthood, compared with only .89 of a year for male priests.

The data suggest that women have to jump higher to get less far.

Bishops Who Ordained

Over half (53.6%) of the women ordained as priests have been ordained by under one-fifth (19.6%) of the bishops who have ordained twelve or more women.

Bishops Who Have Ordained Women Clergy Now Living*

Descending by #   Swing 68 Grein 39 Spong 38
Griswold 34 Walmsley 34 Borsch 30 Burrill 30
Anderson RM 28 McGehee 28 Ogilby 27 Hunt 25
Moore P Jr 24 Walker 24 Belshaw 22 Dennis 22
Allan 21 Bartlett 21 Haines 20 Coburn 19
Lee PJ 19 Hall 18 Hathaway 18 Johnson 18
Thompson 18 Atkinson 17 Black 17 Dyer 16
Eastman 15 Jones EW 15 Ladehoff 15 Lee 15
Ray 15 Wood 15 Coleridge 14 Righter 14
Vest 14 Warner 14 Estill 13 Jones WA 13
Mallory 13 Moody 13 Primo 13 Rusack 13
Shimpfky 13 Trelease 13 Whitaker 13 Johnson DE 12
McKelvey 12 McNutt 12 Thornton 12 Walker O 12
White 12 Winterrowd 12 Kerr 11 Lewis 11
Sanders WE 11 Spears 11 Theuner 11 Williams 11
Zabriske 11 Schofield CO 10 Wetmore 10 Bowman 9
Burt 9 Chalfant 9 Child 9 Cole 9
Doss 9 Hampton 9 Harris BC 9 Light 9
Swenson 9 Wimberly 9 Wolf 9 Beckham 8
Benitez 8 Blanchard 8 Carral 8 Hastings 8
Hughes 8 Jones CI 8 Kimsey 8 Krumm 8
Miller 8 Moodey 8 Reed 8 Rowthorn 8
Sims 8 Smith JH 8 Stewart 8 Weinhauer 8
Wolfrum 8 Barrett 7 Birney 7 Buchanan 7
Cerveny 7 Charles 7 Garver 7 Harris 7
Hart 7 Jones BG 7 Lamb 7 Leighton 7
MacNaughton 7 Rath 7 Spofford 7 Creighton* 6
Donovan 6 Duvall 6 Epting 6 Gray DM 6
Gressle 6 Heistand 6 Jones 6 Lee EL 6
Moore 6 Myers 6 Patterson 6 Pettit 6
Porteus 6 Stanton 6 Sterling 6 Tharp 6
Appleyard 5 Bates 5 Carr 5 Davidson 5
Gilliam 5 Jelinek 5 Morton 5 Sanders 5
Stough 5 Tennis 5 Van Duzer 5 Welles 5
Wissemann 5 Arnold 4 Browning 4 Charleston 4
Charlton 4 Cochrane 4 Harris, GC 4 Joslin 4
Longest 4 Mayson 4 Maze* 4 McNairy 4
Ottley 4 Payne 4 Reynolds 4 Robertson* 4
Robinson 4 Rowley 4 Shaw* 4 Smalley 4
Smith PA 4 Vache 4 Anderson 3 Anderson CB 3
Bailey 3 Brown JB 3 DeWitt 3 Dickson 3
Donegan 3 Folts* 3 Folwell 3 Frey 3
Gray FC 3 Grew* 3 Hargrove 3 Howe JW 3
Hulsey 3 Jecko* 3 Johnson RC* 3 Johnson RH 3
Krotz 3 McAllister 3 McLeod 3 Meeks 3
Rockwell 3 Salmon 3 Terry 3 Turner 3
Wiedrich 3 Allison 2 Ashby 2 Bane* 2
Bennison* 2 Bp of Cntrl NF 2 Cadigan 2 Clark 2
Cochran 2 Corrigan 2 Davis 2 Dixon 2
Elebash 2 Frensdorff 2 Gooden 2 Gordon 2
Gulick* 2 Henderson* 2 Ilhoff 2 Keller 2
Kelshaw 2 Marble 2 Marmion 2 Marshall* 2
Powell* 2 Ramos 2 Said* 2 Sanders BS 2
Soto 2 Stevenson 2 Talton 2 Valentine 2
Villavicencio-Caceres 2 Vogel 2 Wallace 2 Wyatt 2
Alard* 1 Alexander 1 Baden 1 Baharona 1
Ball 1 Beckwith 1 Belden 1 Bp of Brasilia 1
Bp of Niagara 1 Bp of ON 1 Bp of PR 1 Burgess 1
Chang* 1 Crittenden 1 Crowther 1 Currigan 1
Denig 1 Denig 1 Dimmick 1 Fairfield 1
Frade 1 Gonzalez 1 Gray 1 Herlong 1
Holquin 1 Hopkins 1 Johnson B 1 Jones E 1
Jones WJ Jr 1 Keyser 1 Larrea 1 Lee PK 1
Leidel* 1 Martin 1 McArthur 1 Moore WM Jr 1
Mosley 1 Murray 1 Price* 1 Richardson 1
Rockwell 1 Saucedo 1 Scruton* 1 Selway 1
Shahan 1 Sherman 1 Shipps 1 Smith, A* 1
Sorge 1 Stark 1 Wilson CJ 1 Wolf, G* 1
Unidentified bishops 12            

*Denotes a bishop consecrated after 1993. This table was prepared in May 1998.

Note: The Clerical Directory often does not distinguish between bishops who have the same last surname, so tallies for such bishops will often be inaccurate.


Note:  To create this report, I have analyzed entries in the 1998 Electronic Clerical Directory (NYC: Church Publishing Co., 1998).  I broke the code to enable comparisons across fields and to enable the use of mathematical formulas. The crippled commercial version is nevertheless enormously useful, and I highly recommend it. For ordering information, call 800-223-6602 or write to Church Publishing Co., 445 Fifth Avenue, NYC, NY 10016 Return to the top

Clergy Missing in Action

I understand that there are many clergy who never show up in The Clerical Directory at all because they work outside the Church Pension Fund. My friend Linda Curtiss lcurtiss@cpg.org at the CPF refers to these as "clergy in Limbo," and is interested in documenting those who want to be documented. Given the ways in which women clergy who are listed are marginally deployed, I suspect far more women than men are among the ECUSA clergy missing in action.

I would appreciate notice if you wish to be added to my lists as well, lcrew@newark.rutgers.edu

Joy through you to absolutely everyone!